Posted in politics

An (Alternative) Autumn Statement

(with apologies for my long absence from the blogosphere) (and also to international readers – this is very UK focused)

Who’d be Chancellor of the Exchequer right now? I may be in a minority, but I do find myself empathising with the several dilemmas George Osborne faces. As the government tries to steer a course through the competing priorities of the two parties, the various electoral promises and the future vote calculations, it can’t be fun trying to work out where to dole out the pain.

Six lean years face us in the UK (at least). Well, that’s one less than the famine in Egypt which Joseph predicted, though I wouldn’t bet against it getting extended. The problem is that we didn’t have a Joseph turning up at the beginning of the fat years now passed, telling us what was going to happen. Or at least, not one that anyone listened to. So we didn’t store up our surplus; instead, we enjoyed it. And more too.

It’s easy (or at least easier) to act ethically when things are going well. It’s times like we’re living through now that really test. When there isn’t much to go round, real core values are exposed by the retreating tide. Money and mouth are in the same place, because there’s no alternative.

So – don’t be a low paid public sector worker, seems to be the clearest message. Two year’ pay freeze already, increases of 1% for the next two years, way below inflation, plus the changes to pensions, plus multiple reductions to tax credits for low paid workers and for children. Oh, and national pay bargaining goes over the next year or two as well.

In a democratic society, there are two clear tests which a government must pass if it is to demonstrate that it is acting justly. The temptation of any system of power is to play the system to increase your power, rather than to use your power for the benefit of the members of the system. In a democracy, you do that by pandering to prejudice, and rewarding your supporters. So the tests are these:

  • Are our policies equally just towards those people no-one cares about much?
  • Are our policies equally just towards those people who still won’t vote for us?

No-one’s expecting much joy from the Chancellor at the moment, but we can still demand justice. I’m sure the coalition would argue that that’s what we’re getting. But if 100,000 more children are going to fall into poverty over the next few years because of the cuts, I’d like to see more evidence of where there’s a vision of social justice lying behind them.

One thought on “An (Alternative) Autumn Statement

  1. Glad to see you back blogging. Since I have been critical of a couple of your previous posts where you have ventured into politics/economics, I thought it only right to indicate agreement with much of what you’ve said this time. You have correctly identified how we got into our present predicament, and that the Chancellor has an extremely difficult task trying to allocate the pain fairly and justly. I don’t think he’s made too bad a job of it, and if he really was being wholly partisan, he could have been a lot harder than he was.

    As a pensioner myself, I don’t feel that it’s entirely fair to allow a full inflation-proofed increase to pensioners when most people still in work are getting nothing, and I fear that the same argument could have been applied to other state benefits. So that’s one instance where he was much kinder than most Tory-haters would expect.

    Whatever the rights and wrongs of what he has done, I fear that it could all be blown away by what is about to happen in the Eurozone. Although I admire Frau Merkel’s insistence on prudence and sound money, that was the way the Eurozone should have been operated from the start. But it wasn’t operated that way, and her policy is not a solution to the present crisis. If she continues to get her way, the Eurozone will explode and we will all be a great deal poorer.

Leave a Reply to Malcolm Dixon Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s